Empirical Likelihood

Overview

This vignette demonstrates the empirical likelihood estimator for Not Missing at Random data in the NMAR package. The primary estimand is the full-data mean of the outcome $Y$ under the QLS NMAR model. The method implements the estimator of Qin, Leung, and Shao (2002), using empirical likelihood weights that satisfy estimating equations for the response mechanism and auxiliary moment constraints. For full derivations, see the companion article “Empirical Likelihood Theory for NMAR”.

Key features:

• Supports data.frame (IID) and survey.design objects via the same nmar() API.
• Variance via bootstrap (IID resampling or survey replicate weights).
• Optional standardization of predictors. Weight trimming for robustness.
• Rich S3 surface: summary(), confint(), tidy(), glance(), weights(), fitted().

Quick start

• Specify the model with a two-sided formula: Y_miss ~ auxiliaries | response_predictors.
  • The response model always includes an intercept and the evaluated LHS outcome expression $Y$ for respondents.
  • Variables on the first RHS (left of |) enter only the auxiliary constraints (not the response model).
  • Variables on the second RHS (right of |) enter only the response model (not the auxiliary constraints).
  • Variables on the outcome RHS (e.g., X1 + X2) are auxiliaries. Supply their known population means via auxiliary_means = c(X1 = ..., X2 = ...).
    • Alternatively, set auxiliary_means = NULL to estimate auxiliary means from the full input (unweighted for IID data. Design-weighted for surveys), corresponding to the QLS case that uses $\bar X$ when $X$ is observed for all sampled units.
  • Predictors to the right of | enter only the response model (no auxiliary constraint) and do not need population means.
  • If you want a covariate to enter both the auxiliary constraints and the response model (as in the original QLS setup), include it on both sides, for example: Y_miss ~ X | X.
• Choose the engine: el_engine(...), e.g., el_engine(auxiliary_means = c(X1 = 0), variance_method = "bootstrap", standardize = TRUE).
• Fit: nmar(formula = Y_miss ~ X1 + X2 | Z1 + Z2, data = df_or_design, engine = el_engine(...)).
• Inspect: summary(), confint(), weights(), fitted(), and fit$diagnostics.

Data-frame example

We simulate an NMAR mechanism where the response probability depends on the unobserved outcome.

set.seed(123)
library(NMAR)

N <- 500
X <- rnorm(N)
eps <- rnorm(N)
Y <- 2 + 0.5 * X + eps

# NMAR response: depends on Y
p <- plogis(-1.0 + 0.4 * scale(Y)[, 1])
R <- runif(N) < p

dat <- data.frame(Y_miss = Y, X = X)
dat$Y_miss[!R] <- NA_real_

engine <- el_engine(auxiliary_means = c(X = 0), variance_method = "none", standardize = TRUE)
# Fit EL estimator
fit <- nmar(
  formula = Y_miss ~ X,
  data = dat,
  engine = engine
)

summary(fit)
#> NMAR Model Summary
#> =================
#> Y_miss mean: 1.878660
#> Converged: TRUE 
#> Variance method: none 
#> Variance notes: Variance skipped (variance_method='none') 
#> Total units: 500 
#> Respondents: 150 
#> Call: nmar(Y_miss ~ X, data = <data.frame: N=500>, engine = empirical_likelihood)
#> 
#> Missingness-model coefficients:
#>              Estimate
#> (Intercept) -1.570694
#> Y_miss       0.366754

Probit family:

engine <- el_engine(auxiliary_means = c(X = 0), family = "probit", variance_method = "none", standardize = TRUE)

fit_probit <- nmar(
  formula = Y_miss ~ X,
  engine = engine,
  data = dat
)
summary(fit_probit)
#> NMAR Model Summary
#> =================
#> Y_miss mean: 1.880128
#> Converged: TRUE 
#> Variance method: none 
#> Variance notes: Variance skipped (variance_method='none') 
#> Total units: 500 
#> Respondents: 150 
#> Call: nmar(Y_miss ~ X, data = <data.frame: N=500>, engine = empirical_likelihood)
#> 
#> Missingness-model coefficients:
#>              Estimate
#> (Intercept) -0.949678
#> Y_miss       0.217504

Tidy/glance summaries (via the generics package):

generics::tidy(fit)
#>          term   estimate std.error conf.low conf.high component statistic
#> 1      Y_miss  1.8786601        NA       NA        NA  estimand        NA
#> 2 (Intercept) -1.5706942        NA       NA        NA  response        NA
#> 3      Y_miss  0.3667545        NA       NA        NA  response        NA
#>   p.value
#> 1      NA
#> 2      NA
#> 3      NA
generics::glance(fit)
#>     y_hat std.error conf.low conf.high converged trimmed_fraction
#> 1 1.87866        NA       NA        NA      TRUE                0
#>   variance_method jacobian_condition_number max_equation_residual
#> 1            none                  36.83019           5.17808e-13
#>   min_denominator fraction_small_denominators nobs nobs_resp is_survey
#> 1       0.4613402                           0  500       150     FALSE

Outputs and diagnostics at a glance (probability-scale weights sum to 1. Population-scale weights sum to the analysis total $N_\text{pop}$):

head(weights(fit), 10)
#>  [1] 0.008384402 0.008937803 0.004381958 0.014450653 0.006959120 0.007160884
#>  [7] 0.005995129 0.006358571 0.007390444 0.007842733
head(weights(fit, scale = "population"), 10)
#>  [1] 4.192201 4.468901 2.190979 7.225327 3.479560 3.580442 2.997564 3.179285
#>  [9] 3.695222 3.921366
head(fitted(fit), 10)
#>  [1] 0.2385382 0.2237686 0.4564170 0.1384020 0.2873926 0.2792951 0.3336042
#>  [8] 0.3145361 0.2706197 0.2550132
fit$diagnostics[c(
  "max_equation_residual",
  "jacobian_condition_number",
  "trimmed_fraction",
  "min_denominator",
  "fraction_small_denominators"
)]
#> $max_equation_residual
#> [1] 5.17808e-13
#> 
#> $jacobian_condition_number
#> [1] 36.83019
#> 
#> $trimmed_fraction
#> [1] 0
#> 
#> $min_denominator
#> [1] 0.4613402
#> 
#> $fraction_small_denominators
#> [1] 0

Bootstrap variance runs sequentially by default. If the optional future.apply package is installed, it can use the user’s future plan for parallel execution. You can control this via options(nmar.bootstrap_apply = "auto"|"base"|"future").

set.seed(123)
engine <- el_engine(
  auxiliary_means = c(X = 0),
  variance_method = "bootstrap",
  bootstrap_reps = 10,
  standardize = TRUE
)
fit_boot <- nmar(
  formula = Y_miss ~ X,
  engine = engine,
  data = dat
)
se(fit_boot)
#> [1] 0.2761284
confint(fit_boot)
#>           2.5 %   97.5 %
#> Y_miss 1.337458 2.419862

Respondents-only data

If you pass respondents-only data (the outcome contains no NA), provide the total sample size via n_total in the engine so the estimator can recover the population response rate:

set.seed(124)
N <- 300
X <- rnorm(N)
eps <- rnorm(N)
Y <- 1.5 + 0.4 * X + eps
p <- plogis(-0.5 + 0.4 * scale(Y)[, 1])
R <- runif(N) < p
df_resp <- subset(data.frame(Y_miss = Y, X = X), R == 1)
eng_resp <- el_engine(auxiliary_means = c(X = 0), variance_method = "none", n_total = N)
fit_resp <- nmar(Y_miss ~ X, data = df_resp, engine = eng_resp)
summary(fit_resp)
#> NMAR Model Summary
#> =================
#> Y_miss mean: 1.509469
#> Converged: TRUE 
#> Variance method: none 
#> Variance notes: Variance skipped (variance_method='none') 
#> Total units: 300 
#> Respondents: 102 
#> Call: nmar(Y_miss ~ X, data = <data.frame: N=300>, engine = empirical_likelihood)
#> 
#> Missingness-model coefficients:
#>              Estimate
#> (Intercept) -0.886331
#> Y_miss       0.145580

Response-only predictors

You can include predictors that enter only the response model (and are not constrained as auxiliaries) by placing them to the right of | in the formula.

set.seed(125)
N <- 400
X <- rnorm(N)
Z <- rnorm(N)
Y <- 1 + 0.6 * X + 0.3 * Z + rnorm(N)
p <- plogis(-0.6 + 0.5 * scale(Y)[, 1] + 0.4 * Z)
R <- runif(N) < p
df2 <- data.frame(Y_miss = Y, X = X, Z = Z)
df2$Y_miss[!R] <- NA_real_
engine <- el_engine(auxiliary_means = c(X = 0), variance_method = "none", standardize = TRUE)

# Use X as auxiliary (known population mean 0), and Z as response-only predictor
fit_resp_only <- nmar(
  formula = Y_miss ~ X | Z,
  data = df2,
  engine = engine
)
summary(fit_resp_only)
#> NMAR Model Summary
#> =================
#> Y_miss mean: 1.136991
#> Converged: TRUE 
#> Variance method: none 
#> Variance notes: Variance skipped (variance_method='none') 
#> Total units: 400 
#> Respondents: 139 
#> Call: nmar(Y_miss ~ X | Z, data = <data.frame: N=400>, engine = empirical_likelihood)
#> 
#> Missingness-model coefficients:
#>              Estimate
#> (Intercept) -1.019139
#> Y_miss       0.369372
#> Z           -0.232795

Auxiliary means and formulas:

• Names of auxiliary_means must match the model.matrix columns generated by the outcome RHS (for numeric variables this typically equals the variable names. For factors it corresponds to the indicator columns).
• When standardize = TRUE, the engine automatically transforms auxiliary_means to the standardized scale internally and reports coefficients on the original scale.
• Response-only predictors (to the right of |) do not need auxiliary means.

Survey design example

The estimator supports complex surveys via survey::svydesign(). This chunk runs only if the survey package is available. If the survey weights were normalized (for example, rescaled to sum to the sample size), pass an appropriate population total via el_engine(n_total = ...) so that population-scale EL weights are on the intended scale.

suppressPackageStartupMessages(library(survey))
data(api, package = "survey")

set.seed(42)
apiclus1$api00_miss <- apiclus1$api00
ystd <- scale(apiclus1$api00)[, 1]
prob <- plogis(-0.5 + 0.4 * ystd + 0.2 * scale(apiclus1$ell)[, 1])
miss <- runif(nrow(apiclus1)) > prob
apiclus1$api00_miss[miss] <- NA_real_

dclus1 <- svydesign(id = ~dnum, weights = ~pw, data = apiclus1, fpc = ~fpc)
# The engine can infer design-weighted auxiliary means from the full design, 
# or you can supply known population means via auxiliary_means.
engine <- el_engine(auxiliary_means = NULL, variance_method = "none", standardize = TRUE)

fit_svy <- nmar(
  formula = api00_miss ~ ell | ell,
  data = dclus1,
  engine = engine
)
summary(fit_svy)
#> NMAR Model Summary
#> =================
#> api00_miss mean: 667.708681
#> Converged: TRUE 
#> Variance method: none 
#> Variance notes: Variance skipped (variance_method='none') 
#> Total units: 6194 
#> Respondents: 65 
#> Call: nmar(api00_miss ~ ell | ell, data = <survey.design: N=6194>, engine = empirical_likelihood)
#> 
#> Missingness-model coefficients:
#>              Estimate
#> (Intercept) -1.246046
#> api00_miss   0.000168
#> ell          0.019037

Practical guidance

• Trimming: Use a finite trim_cap to improve robustness when large weights occur.
• Solver control: set control = list(xtol = 1e-10, ftol = 1e-10, maxit = 200) for tighter tolerances if needed. Globalization details are managed internally by nleqslv.
• Standardization: standardize = TRUE typically improves numerical stability and comparability across predictors and auxiliary means.
• Diagnostics: Inspect fit$diagnostics (Jacobian condition number, max equation residuals, trimming fraction) to assess numerical health and identification strength.
• Response-only predictors: Variables to the right of | do not need to appear on the RHS of the outcome formula. They enter only the response model. Auxiliary means must be supplied only for variables on the outcome RHS.
• Inconsistent auxiliaries: If provided auxiliary means are grossly inconsistent with the respondent support, the engine will issue a warning via auxiliary inconsistency diagnostics and the solver may fail or yield highly concentrated weights. Consider revisiting the constraints, relaxing them, or using trim_cap.

Troubleshooting:

• Extreme weights: You can set a finite trim_cap.
• Ill-conditioned Jacobian (large fit$diagnostics$jacobian_condition_number): You may tighten solver tolerances via control = list(xtol=..., ftol=..., maxit=...).
• Convergence issues: check fit$diagnostics$max_equation_residual, rescale predictors (standardize = TRUE), or reduce the number of constraints.

Solver control and notes

• Control example: increase iterations and tighten tolerances via control (passed to nleqslv):

ctrl <- list(maxit = 200, xtol = 1e-10, ftol = 1e-10)
eng_ctrl <- el_engine(auxiliary_means = c(X = 0), variance_method = "none", control = ctrl)
invisible(nmar(Y_miss ~ X, data = dat, engine = eng_ctrl))

References and further reading

• Qin, J., Leung, D., and Shao, J. (2002). Estimation with survey data under nonignorable nonresponse or informative sampling. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 97(457), 193-200. doi:10.1198/016214502753479338
• Chen, J. and Sitter, R. R. (1999). A pseudo empirical likelihood approach to the effective use of auxiliary information in complex surveys. Statistica Sinica, 9, 385-406.
• Wu, C. (2005). Algorithms and R codes for the pseudo empirical likelihood method in survey sampling. Survey Methodology, 31(2), 239-243.
• For implementation details, see the companion article “Empirical Likelihood Theory for NMAR”.

sessionInfo()
#> R version 4.5.2 (2025-10-31)
#> Platform: x86_64-pc-linux-gnu
#> Running under: Ubuntu 24.04.3 LTS
#> 
#> Matrix products: default
#> BLAS:   /usr/lib/x86_64-linux-gnu/openblas-pthread/libblas.so.3 
#> LAPACK: /usr/lib/x86_64-linux-gnu/openblas-pthread/libopenblasp-r0.3.26.so;  LAPACK version 3.12.0
#> 
#> locale:
#>  [1] LC_CTYPE=C.UTF-8       LC_NUMERIC=C           LC_TIME=C.UTF-8       
#>  [4] LC_COLLATE=C.UTF-8     LC_MONETARY=C.UTF-8    LC_MESSAGES=C.UTF-8   
#>  [7] LC_PAPER=C.UTF-8       LC_NAME=C              LC_ADDRESS=C          
#> [10] LC_TELEPHONE=C         LC_MEASUREMENT=C.UTF-8 LC_IDENTIFICATION=C   
#> 
#> time zone: UTC
#> tzcode source: system (glibc)
#> 
#> attached base packages:
#> [1] grid      stats     graphics  grDevices utils     datasets  methods  
#> [8] base     
#> 
#> other attached packages:
#> [1] survey_4.4-8   survival_3.8-3 Matrix_1.7-4   NMAR_0.1.2    
#> 
#> loaded via a namespace (and not attached):
#>  [1] jsonlite_2.0.0    compiler_4.5.2    Rcpp_1.1.1        nleqslv_3.3.5    
#>  [5] parallel_4.5.2    jquerylib_0.1.4   globals_0.19.0    splines_4.5.2    
#>  [9] systemfonts_1.3.1 textshaping_1.0.4 yaml_2.3.12       fastmap_1.2.0    
#> [13] lattice_0.22-7    R6_2.6.1          generics_0.1.4    Formula_1.2-5    
#> [17] knitr_1.51        future_1.69.0     desc_1.4.3        DBI_1.2.3        
#> [21] bslib_0.10.0      rlang_1.1.7       cachem_1.1.0      xfun_0.56        
#> [25] fs_1.6.6          sass_0.4.10       cli_3.6.5         pkgdown_2.2.0    
#> [29] progressr_0.18.0  digest_0.6.39     lifecycle_1.0.5   evaluate_1.0.5   
#> [33] listenv_0.10.0    codetools_0.2-20  ragg_1.5.0        mitools_2.4      
#> [37] parallelly_1.46.1 rmarkdown_2.30    tools_4.5.2       htmltools_0.5.9